After like forever of deliberation, I decided on...
The Harry Potter series
by JK Rowling.
This was a surprisingly easy decision to make.
Like most of the kids in my generation, I grew up anticipating the release of each book and movie to the point of extreme excitement and I ate up everything that the Harry Potter-verse could give me. I begged my mum to buy me the trivia games and chocolate frogs and the dolls... Basically everything.
Then why do I not love the series anymore? What caused the huge disconnect?
It was disappointing for me as an adult to come back to the series and to realise that there was so much that could have gone right. From the movies, one of the biggest things that bugged me the most was the switch of Lavender Brown from black to white when she became Ron Weasley's love interest. How is that not severely messed up???
From the books, the source of all Harry Potter lore, I found the portrayal of Severus Snape as a redeemed hero very disturbing. Honestly, this dude was way undeserving of Harry naming a kid after him. Snape is one of the most internally screwed up people the entire series. A bully of little children (that's gross guys please don't try to justify that) and deliberately cruel by nature (look at what he did to Remus Lupin!), he could never have been "one of the bravest people" Harry knew. I mean, there's Hagrid, for god's sake.
We don't only have the case of undeserving characters stealing the limelight but also the case of brilliantly written characters emerging sporadically and rarely, with little dynamic impact on the audience because of how little they're emphasised. There's Hagrid, for one. Mrs Weasley. Shacklebolt. Hermione (don't get me started on how underrated she is). Fleur. Oh god, I could keep going.
I'm not going to deny the richness of the world, but I have to say that it's so incredibly flawed. The lack of racial representation is one other thing. The whole thing about Dumbledore being gay but it being nowhere in the books (god, I hate when this happens - you take credit for "contributing" to the LGBTQA movement without actually contributing to it).
This series, for all its greatness, could have been so much more and I guess I fell out of love with it when I looked at it critically as an adult. It was a great series for me, but I doubt that this is one I'd really recommend to kids.


